Benjamin Rose: Financial Remedy Negotiation at Work

A long-standing financial remedy dispute, in which allegations of domestic abuse had been made, concluded with an agreed settlement approved by the court, bringing the financial proceedings to an end without the need for a contested final hearing.

The distance between the parties at the outset was substantial. W's opening position sought a payment of £240,000, advanced against a valuation of the former matrimonial home in excess of £500,000. That valuation ultimately proved significantly above the independent evidence, with the Single Joint Expert valuing the property at £320,000 to £340,000. H's opening offer was £52,000.

Following negotiation, the parties reached agreement at £85,000.

The settlement provided for a lump-sum payment in return for the transfer of the former matrimonial home, subject to the agreed payment and mortgage arrangements. It also addressed continuing responsibility for education costs, while otherwise achieving a clean break in relation to the parties' financial claims.

The case illustrates the value of effective negotiation in financial remedy proceedings. Despite entrenched opening positions, a significant disagreement over valuation and the wider background to the dispute, it was possible to narrow the issues and achieve a resolution which avoided the expense, uncertainty and emotional burden of a contested final hearing.

From £240,000 and £52,000 opening positions to an agreed settlement of £85,000: a practical example of financial remedy negotiation at work.

Benjamin is ranked as a Tier 2 Leading Junior in Financial Remedy work, despite only being called in 2024, he is available for all aspects of Financial Remedy work, including instruction as a PFDR Judge and Evaluator.

Next
Next

Benjamin Rose represents company directors in High Court unfair prejudice dispute.